Autotrader’s Deal Builder isn’t just another product tweak. It’s a disruptive structural shift in how used cars are bought and sold online and dealers can feel the ground moving under their feet. For years Autotrader played a fairly neutral host, the marketplace where dealers paid increasingly handsomely for leads but kept ownership of the tango between buyer and seller. Deal Builder flips that. It pulls negotiations, finance steps, part-exchange valuations and the vital early dealer-customer chat into Autotrader’s own funnel adding a new commission to variable costs.

Dealers are no longer shaping the first conversation. They’re reacting to it.

At a glance that might simplify the process for the buyer – even more appealing to some? But for dealers it means the nuances that make a sale happen; gauging buyer intent, framing the value of the car, uncovering their real needs, building rapport, have already been flattened by a scripted online journey. Price becomes the headline act. Specification, condition and service history become afterthoughts. The sales wizard on the phone or forecourt who can turn a researching caller or hesitant browser into a committed buyer no longer gets to weave their magic until it’s far too late. Many dealers see that not as convenience but as a strangulation of their craft. No wonder this has become the straw that broke the camel’s back for already disgruntled dealers and Autotrader contracts have been cancelled.

But even with Deal Builder, removing yourself from Autotrader in 2025 is like stepping off the M25 at 8am weekdays and hoping the A-roads will deliver the same traffic. You cut yourself out of the busiest shop window in the country. That risk is amplified by the rise of so-called ‘Zero Click’ behaviour. To an increasing extent searchers are no longer hopping from platform to platform, comparing listings, digging into dealer sites or ringing up on a whim. They’re skim reading synthesised summaries generated by AI that sit above the results. If a car search query gets answered directly in a neat little paragraph; price ranges, typical condition, popular models, even directing them to the dealer with the greatest AI savvy, the user might never reach the listings at all.

This is the new hazard. It’s not simply that buyers won’t click through. It’s that discovery is now mediated by machines distilling the market down to a few tidy facts. Dealers who once relied on strong photography, punchy descriptions and a competitive price for that particular car now find their efforts abstracted into an AI-authored digest that doesn’t mention them, their car or their service. Even when shoppers do hit a listing page, in our ADHD world they’re being conditioned to make faster decisions with less context. Cars outside those first handful of ‘best fit’ results are ghosted before they’ve even had a chance.

Put Deal Builder and Zero Clicks together and the picture gets darker. Dealers leaving Autotrader lose control over a funnel they disliked, but they also lose access to the only marketplace still large enough to push past the AI summaries and land real eyes on stock. Meanwhile the secondary platforms they retreat to don’t have the critical mass to surface above the Zero Click fog. A dealer might regain their autonomy only to find there’s no-one left to talk to.

It isn’t terminal for the trade. Those who invest in their own digital presence; take social media seriously, craft richer websites and vehicle pages, create informative video walk-arounds, encourage reviews, restructure their websites to answer conversational searches, build first-party email lists and get serious about local search can carve out their own lane.

Community reputation, repeat custom and transparent after-sales support still matter in ways algorithms cannot capture.

But make no mistake. The combination of Autotrader centralising the sales journey and search engines becoming subordinate to AI search is a huge double whammy. Dealers will be squeezed from the marketplace side and the discovery side.

Navigating this reality will take sharper thinking than the industry has been asked for in years.

—

Steve Coulter is a four decade Automotive Industry professional now running a creative agency specialising in AI Search, Digital Transformation and Brand Engagement.