If your dealership website is seeing fewer visitors than it was a year ago, you’re not imagining it. Some of that declining traffic is a direct result of how artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping the way people search online and the rules are changing faster than most dealers realise.
Over the last 18 months as a research project I’ve been studying the effect of AI technology on Internet search. New agency disciplines like Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) Conversational Search (CAI) and Answer Optimisation (AO) all drive AI Search Summary results including the citation links.
The fact is – Customers are increasingly getting the answers they need in the AI Summary at the top of the search results (SERPS) without ever clicking through to your website. That’s not a temporary blip, it’s a structural shift in how search works. There’s every chance you are burning your Pay Per Click (PPC) budget.
Here’s another steer – don’t chase every new AI tool that lands in your inbox, an endless wave of shiny new products promising to revolutionise your digital presence. Instead go back to basics.
Review what you already have, identify the gaps, and fix your foundations first.
UK dealers are being targeted by an ever-growing number of AI marketing vendors, many of whom are selling solutions to problems dealers haven’t fully understood yet – I wrote an article called The Comprehension Gap. Understanding the landscape clearly is the essential first step. Some solutions don’t even need AI to resolve them.
The Language You Need to Know
To make sense of what’s happening, it helps to get comfortable with a handful of key terms that are increasingly shaping how dealers think about their digital presence.
SEO (Search Engine Optimisation) is the practice most dealers are already familiar with – building website content that ranks well in Google keyword searches and earns free, organic traffic. It remains important, but it’s no longer the whole picture. In fact Semrush, a leading analytics provider, recently quoted a 1/3 drop off in search appearances for popular search terms because of ‘position zero’ AI summaries. Those enquiries are going to the forward thinking supplier who, ahead of the game in the world of GEO, is already being cited in AI search and AI App results – and will benefit from early adopter status forever.
Position Zero refers to the featured AI generated snippet that appears at the very top of Google results, providing a direct answer to a search query without the user needing to click any link. Appearing here means visibility without traffic, which is precisely the problem.
LLMs (Large Language Models) – as explained by Prof. Hannah Fry on the BBC this week – are the AI tools driven by state of the art electronic chips that are increasingly influencing how people search and make decisions. These include Google Gemini, ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity, platforms that millions of UK consumers now turn to for recommendations, comparisons, and buying guidance.
Schema Markup (sometimes called Website Schema) is structured data added to a website’s backend that consistently labels content, vehicles, reviews, services – so that search engines can properly understand it. It helps generate richer search results and improves click-through rates. Many dealer websites in the UK lack this entirely.
GEO (Generative Engine Optimisation) is perhaps the most important new concept for dealers to grasp. Where SEO is about ranking in traditional search, GEO is about structuring and creating content so it can be easily understood, cited, and summarised by AI tools. Think of it as SEO for the AI era. Unlike traditional SEO, which tends to return the same results for the same keyword, GEO is highly personalised, the same query from two different buyers can produce completely different AI-generated answers, pulling from reviews, forums, and third-party sources alongside your own website.
Prompt Visibility refers to how frequently and prominently your dealership, brand, or specific information appears in AI-generated responses. If an AI tool is recommending dealerships near a customer, does your name come up – and in what context?
Agentic AI is the next frontier. Unlike AI tools that simply provide information, Agentic AI can independently plan, make decisions, and execute multi-step tasks. In a retail automotive context, this means AI that could guide a buyer through the entire purchase journey, from initial research to booking a test drive, with minimal human involvement. This is not science fiction; early versions of this capability already exist. LLMs were initially created to drive Chatbot conversations.
Hallucinations are incorrect results appearing in AI search summaries that could affect a contact or even a loss of reputation. AI is in the ‘Model T Ford’ era, it is not always correct and you need to be testing search terms for accuracy as part of your reputation management.
What This Means for U.K. Dealers
The practical implications are significant. Every positive customer review matters more than ever, because AI tools draw on that content when forming recommendations. An authentic dealer with consistently strong, genuine reviews is far more likely to appear in AI-generated responses than one whose online reputation is thin or inconsistent.
Critically, responses to reviews also need to feel human and genuine – AI can detect overly automated or templated replies, and this affects how credibly your dealership is represented. You cannot rely on AI in most cases ChatGPT writing your content – it’s great for writer’s block, but rewrite ideas in your personal tone.
Your website content needs to answer real questions clearly and directly. Generic manufacturer copy doesn’t help AI understand what makes your dealership distinct. Pages that explain finance options, compare models, or provide genuinely useful local information are the kind of content that both search engines and AI tools favour.
From a technical perspective, your website needs to be accessible to AI crawlers in the first place. A significant number of dealer sites inadvertently block tools like ChatGPT and Google’s AI systems through robots.txt settings or security configurations – meaning those tools simply cannot recommend them, regardless of how good their stock or pricing is. Does your supplier understand llms.txt and is this included in your website back end? These are now questions you need answers to.
The fundamentals; fast loading websites, clean data, honest content, and a credible presence across all digital platforms haven’t changed. What’s changed is how much they matter, and what gets built on top of them.
Steve Coulter is a four decades Sales and Marketing expert with a career in the Automotive Industry and involved in state of the art Digital Marketing since 1999.